Thriving Communities Programme Evaluation
Oldham Council, along with system partners through the Oldham Cares Partnership, has been delivering the Thriving Communities programme, which aims to deliver intervention and prevention services in community settings to support people with physical, mental, and social health and wellbeing needs. The aim of the programme was to reduce reliance on long-term, high-cost services across health and social care, specifically focussing on reducing social isolation and the impacts on the wider determinants of poor health and wellbeing (low confidence, employability, and skills development etc.). The £2.69m programme was delivered with a whole-system approach, with collaboration between local government, VCFSE partners, and health organisations.
The Human Engine team were commissioned to undertake a mixed methods evaluation of the programme to investigate the benefits realised from the programme, the challenges it faced, the return on investment and experiences and perceptions of those who participated in the initiatives. Central to this was understanding and navigating a complex system, its stakeholders and differing motivations and associated benefits and promoting place-based working.
The evaluation undertook a mixed methods approach, combining qualitative and quantitative research to prevent a well-rounded and comprehensive review of the programme.
The evaluation included:
Assessment of national best practice and building on secondary research to compare and contrast Oldham’s successes, challenges and lessons learned
Engagement with over 100 stakeholders from across system partners, including local government, health (including clinicians, managers, and commissioners), VCFSE sector, police, housing and programme participants / service users
Engagement through 1:1 sessions, workshops, focus groups, surveys and project visits
Complex analysis of over 75,000 quantitative data points
Assessment of the wellbeing impact on service users using ONS4 methodology to assess life satisfaction, worthwhileness, happiness, and anxiety pre and post engagement with the programme
Evidencing of key cross system outcomes and metrics, determining differing drivers for change across system partners
Assessment of the Logic Model used for the programme to determine its viability and suitability for future programmes of similar scope
A full mixed methods evaluation of the Thriving Communities Programme, evidencing experiences and perceptions of key stakeholder groups, including service users
An eight-point conclusion and eight-point recommendation summary with specific recommendations for stakeholder groups – 1) the local public service system, 2) Oldham Council, 3) Oldham VCFSE sector
An evidence base that was used to secure future funding for the services once the programme ends in March 2022
'Oldham Council commissioned Human Engine to deliver the evaluation of our Thriving Communities Programme during 2021. They delivered the evaluation through a mixed methodology approach, and delivered outcomes as described in the Case Study in the Autumn of 2021.
Throughout the work Human Engine were an excellent partner to work with. They were mindful of, and flexible to, the expectations of a range of senior stakeholders involved in the project. We had regular engagement with them throughout the process, and they were very communicative and responsive, raising risks and issues as they arose. They always had a professional approach to their work with the project team, and with the large number and range of local stakeholders engaged in the evaluation. Human Engine also supported us in effectively communicating the findings of the evaluation, as well as the underpinning methodology. The final reports were well presented and clear. Human Engine were also willing to put time into working with wider system partners to deliver the Social Value commitments within their tender.'
Human Engine is a Financial Times top-ranked management consultancy with specialisms in strategy, change, digital, commercial and projects.
It was founded in 2018 with a belief that the public sector deserves better than it gets from traditional consulting firms – more human, more personal and more knowledgeable of the reality of delivering modern public services.
We have worked with dozens of public sector organisations to help transform their strategies, operations and cultures to be more agile, commercial and entrepreneurial in order to achieve financial sustainability and improved outcomes for customers and communities.
Our mission is to help individuals and organisations to do the best work of their lives. We do this by blending first-hand experience of the problems we help our clients solve with award-winning consulting expertise and an approach based on trust, collaboration and partnership.